American Idol Top 12 picks – Pick and Win!

Written by: George Bounacos

Of course it’s too early to make picks when you’re still at 20 contestants. That’s the fun. And GG and I will surely take to the airwaves again and handicap the actual American Idol top 12 when they’re announced.

For now, here is who I’m going with (remember that I had Joe Munoz in there at the beginning of the season)

  1. John Park
  2. Lee Dewyze
  3. Lilly Scott
  4. Crystal Bowersox
  5. Siobhan Magnus
  6. Andrew Garcia
  7. Katie Stevens
  8. Katelyn Epperly
  9. Casey James
  10. Jermaine Sellers
  11. Haley Vaughn
  12. Alex Lambert beats Todrick Hall for the last slot

Add your top 12 picks as a response here.  I buy the person who gets the most correct a $25 Amazon gift certificate.  If it’s a tie, we pick a name from the people who tied with the most correct.  Contest ends March 2, 2010 at 6:00 p.m. eastern time.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Comments

  • Andrew Garcia looks like winning, but he's been hyped so bad and it all turns out that she's one of the worst in there, lol. Nope, Dewyze wins the show anyway, so...
  • roheblius
    I know the judges were nicer, and maybe they were told to be, but man, I was still pretty bothered with last night's show. No one has the total package this season. Even Lee's vocals are scratchy at best.
  • sonicgeorge
    Joan said the same thing. By this time last year, Gokey, Lambert, Allison had all broken from the pack. Even Lil Rounds was an early favorite. Kind of like last year's Andrew Garcia.

    Past years always had someone breaking even if they didn't win: Blake Lewis, Daughtry, Melinda Doolittle. I don't get that from any of the guys.

    And the judges weren't nicer. I think the judges were more on point. Having Randy tee it up for Ellen was smart. But the judges began using the word "frustration" yesterday more than I've ever heard.

    I must say I enjoyed the smackdown of Casey though. Being able to pseudo-shred and doing that on a pop song are two very different things. Even Randy got him.
  • roheblius
    If Ellen is as good tonight as she was last night, I'll write a follow up. I really enjoyed her for the most part. She's still faking it on the music stuff, but she's a charming lady for sure.

    Putting her behind Randy was brilliant, though I still think putting Kara second would be supreme.
  • Hellokittiemama
    My picks are:

    1. Casey James
    2. Lee Dewyze
    3. Michael Lynch
    4.Tim Urban
    5. Alex Lambert
    6.Todrick Hall
    7. Crystal Bowersox
    8. Didi Benami
    9. Lilly Scott
    10. Siobhan Magnus
    11. Michelle Delamor
    12. Lacey Brown
blog comments powered by Disqus